Opened
Sunday, 13 September 2026 at 18:56 UTC·Closes
Wednesday, 16 September 2026 at 18:56 UTC
Foden's red card should have stood; Manchester United were wronged by VAR.
Manchester United sit 13th with 4 points from 3 Premier League games. The derby reaction centres on whether Foden's dismissal was correctly overturned.
Closed to new contributions
Lean support · Most adopted
A red card for dangerous play or violent conduct is rarely overturned on review. If VAR intervened to rescind it, the decision was either soft or the original call was wrong—either way, United were denied a numerical advantage they earned.
Place yourself on the line
41 stances
Stance distribution: Oppose 10.Lean oppose 9.Mixed 3.Lean support 12.Support 7.
OpposeLean opposeMixedLean supportSupport
Oppose20406080Support
Drag the line to try a stance. Sign in to save it. Sign in
