Opened Wednesday, 9 September 2026 at 13:55 UTC Closes Saturday, 12 September 2026 at 13:55 UTC
VAR should not overturn on-field penalty decisions when the referee's call is factually wrong.
A Premier League panel determined that the Brentford penalty at Leeds was an incorrect call by the referee, yet VAR upheld it. This raises the question of VAR's role: should it correct clear refereeing errors or only intervene in cases of obvious missed contact.
Support Most adopted
Once VAR starts correcting factual errors, you get 90 minutes of chaos: every marginal contact becomes reviewable, every soft push becomes a handball inquiry, and the whole system collapses into subjectivity instead of the clear threshold V
Place yourself on the line
43 stances
Stance distribution: Oppose 5.Lean oppose 3.Mixed 2.Lean support 15.Support 18.
Drag the line to try a stance. Sign in to save it. Sign in
Why oppose
Why support
Fanbases
-
Arsenal
lean support 83%
-
Tottenham Hotspur
lean support 67%
-
Everton
lean support 100%
-
Liverpool
lean support 100%
-
Aston Villa
lean support 67%
-
Manchester City
lean support 67%
-
Manchester United
lean support 67%
-
Brighton & Hove Albion
lean support 100%
-
Chelsea
split
-
Ipswich Town
lean support 100%
-
AFC Bournemouth
lean support 100%
-
Crystal Palace
lean support 100%
-
Newcastle United
lean oppose 100%
-
Nottingham Forest
lean support 100%
